Looking for the latest update? See our 2026 comparison here.
The streaming world in 2025 is overcrowded, chaotic and more expensive than ever. Platforms keep raising prices, removing content, releasing weaker originals and announcing constant “membership changes.”
So the real question isn’t “Which platform is the biggest?”
It’s “Which one actually deserves your money?”
In this guide, we break down Netflix, Amazon Prime Video and Disney+ using four critical criteria:
library depth, originals quality, user experience and price-to-value ratio.
Let’s get brutally honest.
1. Library Depth: What Do You Actually Get?
Netflix — Huge variety, inconsistent quality
Netflix still has the broadest global library.
You’ll find everything:
- international crime dramas
- Korean hits
- anime
- documentaries
- reality shows
- stand-up specials
- micro-budget experiments
But here’s the truth: along with great shows, Netflix also produces a massive amount of filler. You can scroll for 20 minutes and still not find anything worth watching.
Verdict: Best for people who love variety and explore many genres.
Amazon Prime Video — Massive catalogue, messy presentation
Prime Video has tons of content, but it feels like a supermarket where premium items sit right next to bargain-bin trash. On top of that, mixing included titles with paid rentals confuses casual users.
However, the advantage is clear: huge Hollywood catalogue + new releases available faster than competitors.
Verdict: Great if you want quantity + new releases, but expect a messy interface.
Disney+ — Focused, premium, but limited
Disney+ is built around its empire:
- Marvel
- Star Wars
- Pixar
- Disney Animation
- National Geographic
If you’re inside that ecosystem, Disney+ is unbeatable.
Outside of it, the library feels small and repetitive.
Verdict: Perfect for families and franchise lovers. Not great for variety-seekers.
2. Original Content: Who Still Takes Creative Risks?
Netflix
Netflix still dominates volume. It releases more originals than any platform in the world.
But quality varies wildly:
For every Stranger Things, Dark, or The Crown, you get dozens of forgettable shows.
Still, the experimental spirit is there. Netflix funds bold creators in multiple countries.
Verdict: Most experimental, most international, but inconsistent.
Amazon Prime Video
Prime releases fewer originals, but when they hit, they hit HARD:
- The Boys
- Fallout
- Reacher
- The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel
Amazon’s philosophy is simple: fewer shows, bigger budgets, larger impact.
Verdict: Lower quantity, higher average quality.
Disney+
Disney+ originals revolve almost entirely around Marvel and Star Wars.
That’s fine for fans, but bad for viewers wanting innovation.
Risk-taking is minimal.
Verdict: Safe, polished, franchise-heavy.
3. User Experience: Which App Respects Your Time?
Netflix — Still the king of UX
Clean design
Fast loading
Sharp previews
Best mobile experience
Best recommendation engine
No platform beats Netflix’s usability.
Prime Video — Improved but still clunky
UI is better than past years but still chaotic.
Mixing rentals with included titles remains confusing.
Disney+ — Simple but shallow
Great visuals, easy categories, smooth playback.
But recommendations are basic and repetitive.
4. Price-to-Value Ratio in 2025
General logic worldwide:
- Netflix: Most expensive but most versatile.
- Prime Video: Almost “free” if you already use Amazon Prime for shipping.
- Disney+: Best family value, cheapest premium content ecosystem.
Final Recommendation: Which Platform Should You Choose?
Choose Netflix if:
- you want the widest range of genres
- you don’t mind skipping filler
- you prefer global content
Choose Prime Video if:
- you already pay for Amazon Prime
- you want big-budget shows + quick access to new movies
Choose Disney+ if:
- your household loves Marvel, Star Wars or Pixar
- you have kids
- you want safe, polished entertainment
⭐ Smartest Money Strategy in 2025:
One “primary” platform + one rotating platform.
- Keep Netflix or Prime all year
- Subscribe to Disney+ for 1–2 months, binge everything, cancel
- Rotate platforms without wasting money
This method gives you the BEST shows without paying for all services nonstop.
